
Episode 1097 • 42 min
Inside the ACGME Rewrite: Trainees and Program Directors on the Proposed Common Program Requirements
Share
The ACGME has proposed the biggest rewrite of the Common Program Requirements in years, cutting the number of requirements by 43% with the goal of reducing the burden on programs. What does that mean for the trainees these rules are meant to protect and for the programs that train them? CoSEF residents Drs. Mckenzie Roebuck and Dalton Hegeholz sit down with Dr. Kari Rosenkranz and Dr. Jonathan Dort. Both are surgical program directors and serve as president and president-elect, respectively, of the Association of Program Directors in Surgery (APDS). They discuss what’s changing and what we can all do now.
Key Takeaways:
Some changes are clear wins for trainees: defined at-home call, required pregnancy policies, no routine non-physician work, and clinical coverage for didactics.
Honesty is a tool for change. Accurate ACGME survey responses and work-hour logging help both residents and programs obtain resources.
Fewer written protections put more weight on the 80-hour limit, which only works if hours are reported honestly.- No requirement can fix a broken culture. The written requirements are a backstop, but real protection comes from program leadership and culture.
This is a living document. The ACGME needs to hear quickly if protections erode.
Residents need to stay vocal and get involved locally and nationally, including in writing the policies that replace national ones.
- Collaboration of Surgical Education Fellows (CoSEF), cosef.org, X: @SurgEdFellows
- Mckenzie Roebuck, MD – CoSEF BTK Lead, General Surgery Resident and Surgical Education Research Fellow at Inova Fairfax Medical Campus, mckenzie.rowe@inova.org, Instagram: @mrowemd, X: @mrowemd1
- Dalton Hegeholz, MD – General Surgery Resident and Surgical Education Research Fellow at the University of Utah, Dalton.Hegeholz@hsc.utah.edu, Instagram: @dalton_hegeholz, X: @dhegeholzmd
- Kari Rosenkranz, MD – APDS President, Program Director at Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center
- Jonathan Dort, MD – APDS President-Elect, Program Director at Inova Fairfax Medical Campus
CoSEF perspective piece on the proposed changes:https://zenodo.org/records/23428382
ACGME proposed Common Program Requirements (Residency):https://www.acgme.org/globalassets/pfassets/reviewandcomment/2026/cprresidency_rc_09082026.pdf Review and comment page, with all versions and the Rationale and Impact Statement:https://www.acgme.org/programs-and-institutions/programs/review-and-comment/
Join CoSEF (website and trainee member form):https://surged.notion.site/Membership-3f5e8b163bb949c7a2a9d61840ec46a4
Beyond the Match series on Behind the Knife:
If you liked this episode, check out our recent episodes here: https://behindtheknife.org/listen
Behind the Knife Premium: https://behindtheknife.org/premium
Oral Board Review: https://behindtheknife.org/oral-board
Oral Board Simulator: https://behindtheknife.org/oral-board/simulator
General Surgery Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/general-surgery-oral-board-review
Trauma Surgery Video Atlas: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/trauma-surgery-video-atlas
Dominate Surgery: A High-Yield Guide to Your Surgery Clerkship: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/dominate-surgery-a-high-yield-guide-to-your-surgery-clerkship
Dominate Surgery for APPs: A High-Yield Guide to Your Surgery Rotation: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/dominate-surgery-for-apps-a-high-yield-guide-to-your-surgery-rotation
Vascular Surgery Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/vascular-surgery-oral-board-review
Colorectal Surgery Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/colorectal-surgery-oral-board-review
Surgical Oncology Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/surgical-oncology-oral-board-review
Cardiothoracic Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/cardiothoracic-surgery-oral-board-review
OBGYN Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/course/obgyn-oral-board-review
Surgical Critical Care Review: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/surgical-critical-care-review
ABSITE Question Bank: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/absite-question-bank
EPA Playbook: https://behindtheknife.org/course/epa-playbook
Surgical Instrument Flashcards: https://behindtheknife.org/course/surgical-instrument-flashcards
ABSITE Review: https://behindtheknife.org/course/absite-2026-exam-review
Download our App:
Apple App Store: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/behind-the-knife/id1672420049
Android/Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.btk.app&hl=en_US
Speaker: Hello, hello and welcome back to another episode of Behind the Knife with the collaboration of Surgical Education Fellows, also known as COSEF. Every rule that shapes your training from how long you can work to who supervises you on your first night starts in one document, the ACGME common program requirements.
Speaker: Now, the ACGME is proposing the biggest rewrite
of that document in years. And whether you're a resident or fellow training under these rules or an attending, teaching, and supervising under them, today we walk through what's potentially changing for trainees and programs and what you might do to prepare.
Speaker: I'm McKenzie Roebuck, a surgery resident at Inova Fairfax Hospital and this year's BTK lead for COSEF. My co-host today is fellow
COSEF member Dalton Heggeholz, a general surgery resident at the University of Utah.
Speaker 2: Excited to be here.
Speaker: We are joined today by two very special guests who are both surgical program directors as well as the president and president-elect of the Association of Program Directors in Surgery, Doctors Rosencrans and Dort, although their opinions today are their own and
not official statements of the organization.
Speaker: Welcome.
Speaker 3: Thank you for having us. Thank you
Speaker 2: So briefly for those who don't know, COSEF is a national group of trainees working to improve surgical education. To learn more, visit cosef.org, and trainees, make sure to fill out our member form to get involved. It's linked in the show notes. Some quick background.
Speaker 2:
On September 8th, the ACGME posted a proposed revision of the common program requirements with a target start date of July 1st, 2028. It cuts the number of requirements by 43% with a stated goal of reducing burden on programs. It also reduces the ability of specialty review committees, like surgeries, to set their own rules in several areas,
including work hours.
Speaker: Doctors Rosencrans and Dort, you live the administrative side of residency in a way that trainees don't. What does ACGME compliance burden actually look like for a program director and a coordinator? Are there a lot of requirements that create paperwork without protecting anyone?
Speaker 4: Thanks for the question.
Speaker 4: Yes, there are a lot of
requirements in what is a long manual from the ACGME. But I think what everyone should start with is understanding that all people involved in this, the people in the ACGME, the people in the RRC, the people in the program director community, all have the same goals. It's to
provide the best educational experience, make sure that patient care is, is optimized by that training, and to protect the people who are undergoing that training.
Speaker 3: Any time a program director or program coordinator is spent checking boxes is time taken away from running the program, whether it's designing
curriculum, mentoring residents supporting residents, things like that. So I think autonomy within the program to run itself to meet the goals that Jonathan just mentioned, educating safe, well residents the less burdened that the programs are by administrative requirements, the more they can invest time and energy into the things that I think
might really matter in the long run to the residency.
Speaker: Absolutely. Definitely agree. Do you feel like the current version has a lot of check boxes?
Speaker 3: When you have a group of people who are program directors, former program directors, national leaders in education who believe that we had a document of which 50%
almost was not particularly useful, probably tells us that it wasn't.
Speaker 3: So I think very much what was eliminated for the most part, and I know we'll get into some of the more specific examples meets the intention which is it allows residents more autonomy over their own schedules, even though I know some of that's not
being interpreted that way, and allows programs more autonomy, and also really respects differences across programs where some programs are just not resourced in ways that others are.
Speaker 4: I think that everyone takes the intent of these changes to say, yes, there was a lot of redundancy, there were a lot of unnecessarily
prescriptive elements of it, and they took feedback from all communities, program director community, resident community, and did their best to streamline it to where it takes the burden away from all those parties involved.
Speaker 4: And that everyone agrees that the autonomy allowed to both programs and residents to be able to do their job
effectively is, is going to be what optimizes this whole experience.
Speaker 2: That was a really thoughtful response from the both of you. What struck us about the proposed changes in the document itself, for many of the protections being removed, the answer is, quote, "No impact is anticipated."
Speaker 2: Although how will we know if that's true? That's why we would ask the
ACGME to name the risk each protection was meant to address and how it will monitor that risk once the protection is gone.
Speaker: Sometimes it feels like a lot is put on the ACGME survey, and a lot of residents are afraid to fill those out, I think honestly, 'cause they don't want their programs to get into trouble, and they don't
want them to have citations.
Speaker: And so I worry that, one, it doesn't directly measure some of these things, and then two, that I don't know how honest people feel they can be on them because they love their programs, right? That doesn't mean they're not concerned about certain things.
Speaker 3: And I think if you all have an opportunity as
resident leaders nationally, the message I would get out is the survey is not a weapon.
Speaker 3: It is not something that a disgruntled resident should use to present problems that the program director and the program manager have no awareness of. But I will tell you personally, and again, this represents my personal
opinion I hope the ACGM isn't listening. I love citations. Which is not to say that I want them to be hearing that and give me more, but citations can be really valuable because program directors are advocating for the residency, and sometimes we need a little more clout when we go to our chairs, to our CEOs,
to our, our senior leaders and say, you know, work hours is an easy example.
Speaker 3: Our residents are violating work hours. We're going to go on probation and eventually be shut down. Do you want that to happen, or do you want to help us solve the problem? So as much as you all through this podcast and through other avenues where you have resource and access
to residents, educate them around the survey.
Speaker 3: Citations are okay, and they can be incredibly helpful to the program because it's a way to catalyze meaningful change.
Speaker 4: If you go back in the last few years and look at how many times the common program
requirements have been edited and additions and changes have made, I think you can see that everyone sees this as a living, dynamic document that is representative of the best information they have at the time.
Speaker 4: I don't think anyone on that ROC expects the fact that, that they just put out a perfect document and that it's
gonna have no repercussions. And if they need to go back in two to three years and make more changes, I suspect they would be the first ones to say, "We need to do that." Uh, because they have.
Speaker 4: They, they've proven that in, in their behavior, that they're willing to make those continued adjustments. So I think they have made some efforts to try to get some of that information outside of the single
big survey that goes out annually. And I would encourage residents and programs to be very honest in that feedback.
Speaker 4: I think they want to hear this.
Speaker 3: Each specialty has had some of their own reactions to the proposed requirements, and they will not be implemented until July. But the last I read, they got 2,800 comments from around the country,
and that's why they have this period of comment, is so that people can give a different perspective or offer what they think might be a deleterious impact that hadn't yet been considered.
Speaker 3: So these are not yet written in stone. But to your question, Mackenzie, in terms of how they'll be monitored, I think the ACGME will be extremely reactive if
we see a sudden rise in violations in the eight-hour workweek, for example, which I think from the general surgery perspective, most of the concerns around the requirements were some of the decreases in work hour protection, then there will be a rapid response.
Speaker: That's all great to hear. Thanks for adding that, guys. We wanna be clear that there are some changes that I
think could really be helpful for trainees.
Speaker 2: Definitely. For example, programs under the proposed changes must define and monitor at-home call. Every program needs a pregnancy policy, and lactation time is protected with no makeup.
Speaker 2: Additionally, having to do routine non-physician work is off-limits, and didactics now have to
come with clinical coverage.
Speaker: From your perspectives, what of the upcoming changes do you think will make the biggest difference for trainees and for programs in a positive way? Dr. Rosenkranz, I know you'd mentioned especially for rural programs this could be helpful.
Speaker 3: I think all the things that Dalton just mentioned are really positive changes. In terms of rural and smaller programs, certain
requirements, the change in the ratio of core faculty to residents, for example, there is some chatter online about how that is a very negative change. I don't know that that's true.
Speaker 3: I think some concern coming from the specialties where core faculty are paid separately is a different stressor. But there are smaller
programs where there just isn't a large faculty to draw from. It doesn't mean they don't have high-quality teachings. There were some changes in the definitions around who can be core faculty, for example.
Speaker 3: There are some really great independent hospitals where general surgery residents might cover plastics and neurosurgeon, maybe OBGYN, and those faculty
now can be teaching faculty in general surgery, which I think is only a positive effect. But I think the impetus for that change was because it's happening in smaller independent programs.
Speaker 4: There are some things, just as Dolphin was saying, and you too, Mackenzie, that I love in this. I-- and I think everyone will. So much of the burden on residents right now is, is, is
administrative responsibilities like EMR stuff and the amount of home call, which is blurry in how that fits in, and now it's very well outlined.
Speaker 4: And and the fact that those all now have structure around it, uh, I think is fantastic and very resident positive. The whole pregnancy requirement, uh, you know, that's obviously some personal stuff we've, we've had and
advocated for a long time. And, and if people think, well, most programs did this already, it's very different when it's a requirement because that takes the burden off of the resident to have to ask for the favors and have to, to try to figure things out.
Speaker 4: And, and now it's programmatically required, which is fantastic.
Speaker: Maybe let's get into the work hours a little bit. Kind of like you
guys were mentioning, there are definitely some proposed changes here. For example, in section six point three one, the ACGME proposes that the rest after a twenty-four-hour call drops from fourteen hours to twelve hours, and the stated reason is scheduling burden.
Speaker: It doesn't sound like a big change, but what I'm picturing happening is somebody has a twenty-four-hour call,
leaves at seven AM, drives back and forth home, makes food, goes to sleep, and then comes back at seven PM for another twelve-hour shift or twenty-four-hour shift. And right now, the rules would prevent that.
Speaker: I guess I'm just a little worried about what that could look like for people in programs that maybe aren't quite as awesome as, as you guys are.
Speaker 2:
Yeah, and the proposal also deletes the recommended eight hours between shifts and the every third night call limit because the ACGME says the eighty-hour limit in and of itself makes those violations nearly impossible.
Speaker 2: So I guess our question is, does tracking those between shift and call frequency limits create a lot of work on the program side, or what is your
perspective on that?
Speaker 4: I think at a very specific structural level, you could say why twelve is a little bit easier than fourteen, but obviously that's not the spirit of what everyone is looking at is, is why would you do that?
Speaker 4: I think that if, if a place needs to have something scripted out to not put residents through an
awful schedule, then there's a bigger problem than the fact that something was changed in a specific requirement. I, I think anyone who's committed to resident well-being is not gonna look at this and, and rub their hands together and think, "Oh, I have a chance to abuse residents more."
Speaker 4: I- hopefully every program director's gonna look at this
and say, "We have a little bit of autonomy, and with combinations of, of resident and, and programmatic scheduling, we're gonna do what is best for our patients, but what is still going to protect residents and their well-being and put them at their optimal position," and that the change just for the schedule frequency shouldn't make a difference
at all.
Speaker 4: I think that was the RRC's intent, was that it just allows autonomy without being rigid, and I, I would hope it's every program director's response that I am still going to be the primary person looking out for the well-being of all of these residents, and I'm not gonna put a schedule out that's going to make
anyone more at risk or put patients more at risk because of this.
Speaker 3: I, I think that's really well said. And an expression I like is where you stand depends on where you sit. So it's been really interesting to see people's different perspectives. So I've been trying to think of the interpretation, for example, the every third to
every other night call. And I agree with everything Jonathan already said, which is my perspective is program directors are by definition looking out for their residents, so I don't think they're going to call out this into a draconian, you know, we're gonna squeeze every last minute out and they're, they're gonna only take seven hours and 59 minutes between
the shifts or that type- I was thinking about the, the change in the call frequency, for example.
Speaker 3: And in my mind I was like, that could be a great advantage to a resident who might wanna switch a call shift or two because they have a wedding coming up and they want to take a four-day weekend. So they could switch it to an every other call for a couple shifts to facilitate more time off. So again, where you stand
depends on where you sit.
Speaker 3: I think you can take the perspective that programs or institutions are going to take this and say, "Every resident's gonna be on every other night," but again, mathematically it just doesn't work within the 80-hour work window. But you can take the alternative perspective, which is, "Hey, how could we actually use this to a benefit to allow residents a little more flexibility in
their scheduling?"
Speaker 3: So I personally, and I know this sounds a little too old school, I don't think it's a terrible thing for people to learn to juggle schedules, to learn to work when they may be a little bit tired. But the expense is also you get more time off on the other end because you still can't go over the 80-hour work week.
Speaker 4: And I would say that that some people are a little nervous about saying, "Well, how do y- how can you be sure that 80 hours is gonna stand as that guardrail?" And I would say, "How can you be sure now? If you're in a place where you can't be sure of it now, you won't be sure of it then." But those rules are supposed to stand.
Speaker: Yeah. I- I'm glad you
guys added those perspectives. I think it's really helpful. And overall I think a lot of residents and attendings, we're all trying to move towards more autonomy and not less autonomy. So I think that's a really important point. I guess I worry the 80-hour limit depends on people reporting their own hours.
Speaker: S- there's a ton of studies that show that
residents under-report their hours. And so, you know, they're worried about the loyalty to their program, fear that they're gonna be punished. And so from what I've heard, rules like the 14 hours off and the night call limits are followed more closely because they're visible on a schedule versus sometimes the 80-hour work week.
Speaker: And so it seems like a little
redundancy could be some nice insurance in some cases, so why not keep them in? But I do see your point of for people who want to get to go to something that that could be advantageous for them. But do either of you have any additional thoughts on this?
Speaker 4: I do, and I'm glad you mentioned that.
Speaker 4: I'm gonna actually tag on to a point when
Tara was talking about citations before. I have benefited in our program from accurate reporting of 80-hour overages because that's what I use to go to my administration and say, "We don't have enough AVPs. We don't have enough support group. We don't have..."
Speaker 4: And the accurate recording of those hours that won the
argument and allowed me to get some hires and get some support. So, uh, just like Dr. Rosenkrantz was talking about using citations, I use hours in a positive way, and I, I think nobody should be in a situation where they're scolded for being accurate.
Speaker 4: I think that's the exact information program directors need to get them resources.
Speaker 3: And remember,
there are layers of protection for residents. So if you have a program director, I mean, I would argue no one in the country as a resident should get in trouble for logging appropriate work hours. I think the days of that are long behind us, or I'd like to think that.
Speaker 3: But if you are in a culture where that is a problem,
that's why we have DIOs. That's why you have chairs. That's why you have the ACGME. So there are layers of protection where-- And I, and I realize it's much easier to say than do, and nobody wants to be the whistleblower. But in reality, people need to know when the culture is such that people are being actively punished for lying about or for
telling the truth about work hours.
Speaker 3: Um, back to your question, Mackenzie, in terms of tracking and logging, I think the burden is much more on the residents in terms of the eight or the fourteen hours or however many of the breaks. I don't know that any schedule, no matter how it looks on paper, truth be told, with the exception of putting trackers on residents, which actually
exists and some programs are using the only way to know for real about work hours, it's not what's written on a Q gender or whatever scheduling tool you use, it's what residents are logging, no matter what the breaks between shifts are supposed to be.
Speaker 3: So I f- I think if what comes from these rule changes, knowing that there is a lot of concern on the part of residents around
the country, if what comes is more honest work hour reporting, maybe these changes will all be worthwhile.
Speaker 4: And I'm gonna add one more thing, and that's this needs to be a partnership with all the residents.
Speaker 4: I think in some cases, the intimidation felt by junior residents comes from senior residents, not from program administration. So I think this needs to
be a universally discussed and agreed-upon separation.
Speaker: Yeah, that's what I was gonna say. I know both of you, and I know both of you are fantastic program directors, right?
Speaker: And I know that all of your residents feel comfortable coming to you with issues. I know that's true for both of you, and I think we all know residents at programs
who are not in those situations and who do not feel protected, whether it's by their chief residents or by their, their leadership. And so I think when I read these things, I'm kind of thinking about, well, what about my friends at those programs?
Speaker: What's going to happen to them? I know a prelim resident who's getting completely overworked and can't report
their hours because they're applying right now. Are they gonna be taken advantage of even more?
Speaker 3: That's a great and scary question. And, and it's disappointing, I would say at, at best, to hear that that's still happening
Speaker 4: It is.
Speaker 4: And I would also say that there's nothing in the common program
requirements that's going to change a culture like that, that, that is rotting from the roots out and needs a, a very big overhaul.
Speaker: It hurts, but it's true.
Speaker 3: But, but I think Jonathan makes a great point. If the break is 12 hours, it's still gonna be six in a program like that.
Speaker 3: It's-- That's true. There's not gonna be
any document that can protect from that culture, which goes back to why honest reporting, even if it's on the survey and not weekly work hour reports, can be really beneficial.
Speaker: So another change in the proposed document is talking about mistreatment. Today, programs must provide an environment free from harassment and discrimination is the
wording.
Speaker: Whereas the proposed change is that conduct that is not tolerated and promptly addressed is the new ask. So a single incident the program handled would no longer be citable.
Speaker 2: Yeah. And with that, I, I picture going back to Mackenzie's example of, of a person she personally knows, picturing a
prelim resident who reports being mistreated by an attending.
Speaker 2: Today, that incident is itself a violation which pushes the program to act. Under the proposal, technically just one brief conversation with program leadership or that attending could count as promptly addressed. No fault with the resident, no change in assignment, and no
citation unless it becomes a pattern, which is not well-defined under the proposed changes.
Speaker 2: And the people most likely to be mistreated, women, underrepresented in medicine residents, international graduates, prelims, may feel the least power to report in the first place. And so our concern is, at least my concern is, I find that change
to be a bit too vague.
Speaker 3: This is a change I would love to hear a little more directly from the people who propose them.
Speaker 3: This goes back to something Jonathan said in the beginning. I think the intent is good. Do any of us live in 2026 in a society that is free of any of these things? So I think while it is the ultimate
goal, maybe the change in the requirements is a more realistic goal where, in reality, if there is one issue of mistreatment, depending how egregious, we might fire someone, but more likely than not, the approach is gonna be the same.
Speaker 3: It's gonna be a sit-down conversation. But I feel like it's something program directors can do when they say, "Well, I need to intervene," and this is within the
ACGME guidelines. And if they happen to have senior leadership, a chair or someone who doesn't engage as much, they can invoke these regulations and say, "But this is actually in the, the requirements.
Speaker 3: We need to address this." Where just to say the environment is free of anything bad is so utopian that perhaps it's not
as actionable. I don't know. That's just me thinking out loud. I've thought a lot about this one because I think protecting the culture obviously is critical, and which is the best way to do it, I'm not sure
Speaker 4: Yeah, I have to admit that I, going off of that as well, that my initial reaction to reading this is different than, than hearing about
some of the concerns about it, 'cause my initial reaction was these things happen.
Speaker 4: We don't live in a a perfect world, and that if I look for the intent, and again, we didn't write this, we're not here to defend it, but if I look to the intent, nobody thinks that we're free of, of this. So what this does, if you look
at the way the wording changed, is it assumes it happens, but now the response is under scrutiny.
Speaker 4: Whereas in the original wording, the response was not under scrutiny, it was just whether it occurred, and I think their position is we know these things occur, we wanna see how you're handling it, and that's gonna be part of how we judge this. And I saw that actually as an
insightful positive. But I, now having seen how, how it can also be interpreted exactly the opposite way, and so, uh, it would be interesting to hear a little more about the, the, the specific intent.
Speaker: Yeah, I think that's fair. We want something that's realistic for everybody. So I think the little middle ground might be could you
define what a pattern means, right? Like, what is that? Could you give us a little bit more detail on... I mean, it's, you don't want someone to say, like, give you if it happens three times, right?
Speaker: But a little bit more information on what that actually means might be helpful, 'cause otherwise someone could say a pattern's only if it happens for six months. Things super vague. And I will say, like,
I hope that most people are all looking out for each other and wanna use these to the best, right? But in my head, again, I'm, I'm worried about kind of the worst case scenarios 'cause I feel like a document that talks about kind of the minimum standards should be looking out for the worst case scenarios at the end of the day.
Speaker: But I agree that
overall it shouldn't, hopefully, make a difference
Speaker 2: Yeah, I, I agree with you, Mackenzie, 'cause-- And I think that's where our writeup of the, the COSF perspective on the changes came from, was through the lens of viewing the common program requirements as that, quote-unquote, kind of
bare minimum or maximum protection, I should say, of if things at the local level are not going well, then the ACGME should be the kind of final say and ultimate fallback for protecting the trainee.
Speaker 2: Like you, Dr. Jordan, Dr. Rosenkrantz have mentioned that the ACGME is
there to be the fail-safe. And so that's where our concern was in removing some of those protections from the written document.
Speaker: We said, "ACGME, please protect us."
Speaker 4: I agree.
Speaker: So as we all probably know, mental health remains an integral part of supporting trainees.
Speaker: Studies have shown that about one in six interns report suicidal
ideation, for example. In the new proposal, the revisions remove a requirement for twenty-four/seven confidential mental health access, as well as language saying that there should be no negative consequences for those unable to complete clinical work for various reasons.
Speaker: Do you think this will at all have an impact on our trainees in need of mental health support or those who need to take time off?
Speaker 4: It almost doesn't matter what it says there. I can't imagine any program director who finds a resident in need or who has a resident in need pointed out by other residents or that resident comes to them is not gonna make every resource available to help them.
Speaker 4: I, I think we universally recognize the mental, physical, and
emotional stress that this training puts on everyone, and that our first and foremost job, other-- in addition to looking out for patients, is to look out for our residents. Now to our point, I, I mean, I think it was put in there just so that people didn't get continuous citations, but I think to at least have wording that,
uh, reiterates how important it is to be able to support in that way
Speaker 3: I think this was the one other key component of the proposal that I would love to sit down with the people who are in the room and just get a better understanding of their thought process, knowing again that their mission is resident wellness.
Speaker 3: I suspect that
this is another area where smaller and perhaps rural programs just literally do not have those resources for anyone, never mind residents, and perhaps it was a way to make things a little bit more consistent with what reality is as opposed to what the ideal state would be, which of course would be 24/7
confidential treatment.
Speaker 3: I agree with everything Jonathan said. I think there is nothing more important to program directors, to governing bodies, to residents themselves than resident mental health. But what this impact will be, I honestly don't know, and what the impetus for similarly, I'm not sure, but I suspect it had to do with what resources exist in reality which is a
national crisis.
Speaker: I like your guys' points that maybe if we make things a little bit more realistic for the ones that weren't, hopefully it actually means they're followed more and not less. Going back a little bit to the bigger picture, some of our fears or the concerns maybe is that the burden may be taken off of the programs
in some ways, but that maybe it gets moved over to the trainees who don't have much power to push back because the trainees depend on their programs.
Speaker: And we'll say their chi- including their chiefs too because they do a lot of these things. But for schedules, assessments, promotions, letters, and when a protection becomes locally defined,
that means they are the ones who then need to negotiate it, for it in some circumstances. And so then it doesn't happen.
Speaker 2: Yeah. And to be fair, I think like some of the cuts can be a real relief for the programs, and like you all mentioned, for some of the trainees too as far as having more autonomy and flexibility,
and we do want the changes to be mutually beneficial. So the protections we'd hope to keep are the ones that trainees can't enforce on their own.
Speaker 2: So if the goal is reducing administrative burden, what could the ACGME cut or streamline instead, and what are the main points from your perspectives as program directors that you think are of the
most value or the most pertinent?
Speaker 4: I would say anything that doesn't involve your training as a surgeon, that doesn't teach you how to take care of patients, that doesn't improve your mental, technical, communication or
professionalism skills, that is just a check in the box for some arbitrary administrative ad, is what should be on that chopping block.
Speaker 4: I think that this should be reduced to exactly what you said, Dalton, that every single thing should have a purpose and a definable path to some element
that makes you a better surgeon. And if it doesn't meet that requirement of patient care and residents skill improvement, it shouldn't be there. If you want me to give you specific examples, I, I think, you know, it's great to have to learn about
Speaker 4: In fact, you have to learn about quality, about pa- improvement. I don't think it's the resident's job to change hospital processes. I, I, I think that sometimes we put the onus of some of these meetings and some of these quality initiatives and some
of, uh, uh... That's just a random example of, of yes, you should learn about them.
Speaker 4: Yes, you should know what they mean. Yes, you, you should always be an advocate for improved patient health, but I don't think the administrative burdens of these things should fall onto residents. But does, does that need to be on an ACGME requirement if it has nothing to do with your actual surgical training?
Speaker 4: I don't think so.
Speaker:
Anything else that we haven't brought up yet in this document that caught your guys' attention or the chatter of people in APDS that you'd like to talk about?
Speaker 3: A lot of our program directors, again, within general surgery, first of all, have been very quiet on the topic. The
topics in general, there's not a lot of dissent regarding these changes.
Speaker 3: Does that mean implicit support? I don't know, or just people... I mean, it's a complex document to read, for sure, and maybe people just are not well-versed, so that's possible. But I actually think the administrative burden, and maybe, again, this just speaks to how my program
runs, the decrease is really on the resident side just 'cause there's a little bit less to focus on.
Speaker 3: Um, the one thing that we haven't touched upon at all, and maybe it's 'cause I'm obsessed with it 'cause I have no idea how to do it, but the requirements do need to bob and weave with the times. So subtly written in there, there now is an assessment of, of the resident's ability to
integrate AI into practice.
Speaker 3: That's not how it's written, but that's at least how I interpreted it. And that's where I think that is real, to Jonathan's point. I actually think that's going to be a huge part of your surgical practice, a huge part of what patients are gonna bring to the clinic, so an important thing to evaluate. Do we have the tools to do that?
Speaker 3: I certainly don't, but I
think that's an interesting part of the requirements is they're going to have to keep being a living, breathing document because, to Jonathan's point, how we train surgeons and what the final product is is a living, breathing entity.
Speaker 4: I will often field questions, especially from some of the surgeons of a different generation that, you know, "These residents don't have to go through what I
went through," and I agree with them.
Speaker 4: I abs- without hesitation, I agree with them, and you are right I did not have to spend four hours filling out an EMR. I didn't have to have to account for where I was every 15 minutes of every day. I did not have to do 50 modules of, of saying I read something about sleep deprivation. And
I know what sleep deprivation looks like.
Speaker 4: I mean, I have such a list of things I did not have to do in administrative burden as a resident, and honestly, I think that accounts a whole lot more what drags people down than actually taking care of their patients. And so anything that takes regulatory and administrative
burden off of residents, I am naturally gonna be in favor for it, but it has to be done judiciously.
Speaker 4: And so I actually, Mackenzie, Dalrymple, congratulate the two of you for even doing this, for, for keeping residents engaged and being part of this conversation because you're the ones in the trenches. You know what works and what doesn't work, and that's why it has to remain a continuous
conversation about this.
Speaker 2: I really, really appreciate you saying that. And I think that's one of the things that does kinda-- the sentiment that kinda gets lost between the different generations of people who trained at different times is it's hard for everybody. But what that difficulty looks like is
different every time. And I think you would find different people who would trade the era they trained in for different reasons and who wouldn't trade the era they trained in for other reasons.
Speaker 2: And so I think it's really, really valuable to hear a program director speak on that and recognize it and be in touch with the struggles
that you went through when you were a trainee while also recognizing the struggles that the current generation goes through.
Speaker 3: And that advocacy and that championship from you as residents goes back to what you asked us in the beginning, which is how we-- will we assess the impact?
Speaker 3: You're the voice on the ground,
so as long as you keep the conversation going, that information will trickle to your program directors, to your DIOs, to the ACGME, to anyone who needs to hear it
Speaker 2: It feels like we had a, a really good discussion, and it was really, really great to hear both of your perspectives from the program director side and honestly to hear your
perspectives knowing that you're doing your very best as PDs to think about what is the trainee experience and perspective.
Speaker 2: And so looking at our perspective piece, while we agree with a number of the proposals, the major asks that we put in that perspective piece were, one, keep the eight hours between shifts and
14 hours after call and every third night call limit. Two, restore the no retaliation protection and define promptly addressed for mistreatment.
Speaker 2: Three, keep explicit mental health access. And four, most importantly, state the risk of these changes and how it will be monitored if we're removing protections.
What do you guys think about those asks, and how do you think they could be modified or not?
Speaker 4: I'm gonna go back to what I said earlier, which is absolutely I think we all agree with the necessity for mental health resources.
Speaker 4: I, I think we all agree with zero tolerance for retaliation. It's
that obvious to me that, that, that those things should be exactly what you say. Uh, the shifts in between, I want to see how the-- I want you guys to keep your voice in your response to this because, again, while the stated goal may be the ease of scheduling, in the end, the
goal should be patient well-being and resident well-being, and I think those are the only two metrics that this should be judged on.
Speaker 3: I think having had opportunity to look at your response, you collectively, your group, definitely
highlighted some places where there could be unintended consequence. We know what sleep deprivation does to people. We know how many people are having mental health crises. Mackenzie, you mentioned the one in six residents express suicidal ideation.
Speaker 3: I mean, these are things that probably are a conversation that needs to be had at a much more intensive
level outside a conversation about program requirements. These are really things that we need to start focusing a lot on culture change. I imagine in the airline industry if one in six pilots expressed suicidal ideation, there would be a whole new approach to airline safety That's outside the
scope of this conversation, but I guess it's also a way of saying the program requirements are not going to solve that problem, but we really need to strategize how to solve it another way.
Speaker 3: Well, obviously, as we talked about, some of these might change before the rollout next July. Some of them might not. And I would just encourage you again to be
vocal and get engaged with programs around the country. There aren't that many. There are three hundred and fifty plus or minus. So having representatives from most or all programs at the resident level to have a voice and bring it back to the ACGME 'cause you highlight some real areas that could be of real concern.
Speaker 3: And hopefully,
on a positive note, it will all err toward the side of resident autonomy, which we know is a huge driver of resident wellness. But if that's not the case, we gotta be vocal, and we need to be able to pivot quickly.
Speaker 4: Very well said. I agree with Dr. Georgiev on that. And, and if, if as stated, the intent is to relieve
resident burden but not to disrupt the protections in place, then that's great
Speaker: Yeah, I will say I think really our biggest ask with all of the big changes that have to do with residents is to make sure there are plenty of residents involved at the table.
Speaker: And so thank you both for highlighting
that.
Speaker 3: And get engaged. The ACGME has residents on the RRC. Make sure people get involved, 'cause there's opportunity.
Speaker: So shameless plug here, if this got you thinking about everything else that shapes a trainee's day-to-day from how we're hired, what we're paid, to working conditions and program accountability, check out our recent
three-part series Beyond the Match.
Speaker: We look into some of the most common issues in training and explore what factors or big players might actually be contributing to them. It's related to a lot of what we're talking about today.
Speaker 2: The common thread between that series and today is leverage. Trainees have very little leverage or control over the conditions that they train in, which is why written protections
matter.
Speaker: Okay, so in summary, the ACGME has proposed new changes to the main document that guides requirements for resident and fellow training. Trainees and patients are the people these rules are aimed to protect, and much of what actually happens will be decided by your program and your graduate medical education committee, which oversees every program at your hospital.
Speaker: So here are some ideas of
what you can do now.
Speaker 2: First, you could read our perspective piece linked in the show notes to better understand the potential changes coming to your program. Its appendix lists many of the proposed changes and what we think it could mean for trainees.
Speaker: Second, ask your program director and your GMEC to include trainees in writing the policies that are decided
at the program level, for example, the pregnancy policy, burnout plan, mistreatment reporting process, and absence policy.
Speaker: Or ask if your institution can add new policies to cover some of the ones being removed at the ACGME level.
Speaker 2: And in general, again, find ways to get involved in your institution's GMEC and resident advocacy committees, as well as look for
opportunities at the regional and national levels.
Speaker: Thank you so much to our guests today for your time and expertise.
Speaker: We truly appreciate hearing your perspective, and genuinely, we're all so lucky that you two are the ones in charge.
Speaker 4: It's very kind of you. Thank you, Mackenzie. Thank you, Dalton. Appreciate the invitation for today.
Speaker: Now I hope everyone listening can go forth and dominate the
day
More from General
Colorectal Emergencies Crossover: Navigating Diverticulitis, Gunshot Wounds to the Pelvis, and Toxic Megacolon
EP. 1096 · NOV. 16, 2026 · 53 MIN
Clinical Informatics for Surgeons, Episode 3: AI in the OR and Beyond; Machines That See, Read, and Act
EP. 1094 · NOV. 9, 2026 · 35 MIN
Clinical Informatics for Surgeons, Episode 2: Legal Discovery and Cybersecurity When a Case Goes Wrong
EP. 1093 · NOV. 5, 2026 · 33 MIN
Clinical Informatics for Surgeons, Episode 1: What Is Clinical Informatics, and Why Should Surgeons Care?
EP. 1092 · NOV. 2, 2026 · 29 MIN
USA vs. UK: ASGBI Ep. 11 - Surgeons Are Human Too- Breaking the Silence on Mental Health
EP. 1091 · OCT. 29, 2026 · 43 MIN
